Irish Taxi Forum

Public Area => Taxi Talk => Topic started by: silverbullet on November 03, 2026, 07:43:20 pm

Title: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: silverbullet on November 03, 2026, 07:43:20 pm
https://www.rte.ie/news/courts/2026/1103/1597858-waterford-escooter-bus-collision/ (https://www.rte.ie/news/courts/2026/1103/1597858-waterford-escooter-bus-collision/)

Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 03, 2026, 08:27:45 pm
RIP

Seen one of them JJ Kavanagh buses being driven in a very aggressive manner at DAP a few years back.... was trying to block a private car into a bus stop so he could report the driver for dropping there. Complete looper.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 03, 2026, 08:38:28 pm
Quote
Mr Storan said the jury would hear evidence that data from the tachograph fitted to the bus would put the speed of the vehicle at the time of the collision in the region of 76km/h.  He said the speed limit for that stretch of road was 50km/h.

Mr Storan said the two teenagers had been wearing dark clothing and were travelling on a black e-scooter that did not have a rear light.

The prosecuting barrister said the collision took place as both the bus and e-scooter moved to the right of the road and the impact occurred near the white line in the centre of the road.

Mr Storan said the accused had tested negative for driving under the influence of drink or drugs.

Shame there wasn't a camera on board.  Would be interesting to see how the teenagers in dark clothing on a black e-scooter with no rear light ended up in the middle of the road at 2am?

And the teenagers were 15 & 17.  Was there an age limit for e-scooters back in 2024?  [Google AI: "Age Requirement: You must be aged 18 or older to ride an e-scooter in a public place (this increased from 16 years old on October 2, 2026)"]
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 03, 2026, 09:01:18 pm
Strange not to have a camera on a bus in this day and age. A Dublin Bus driver told me they all have them fitted. The road condition was described as dry with poor visibility in places and the speed limit is 50 kilos/hour yet the (professional) driver was travelling at c.76 kilos/hour at the point of impact according to his tachograph.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 03, 2026, 09:05:12 pm
Dangerous driving is at the top end of the scale.  Was it?  Or careless driving?  Or driving without due care and attention.  I don't know the scale but dangerous driving seems excessive to me.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 03, 2026, 09:10:49 pm
76 kilos/hour in a 50 kilo/hour zone seems pretty dangerous to me, especially with poor visibility.... on a bus. Death by dangerous driving would seem appropriate.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Taxi driver42 on November 04, 2026, 07:40:24 am
76 kilos/hour in a 50 kilo/hour zone seems pretty dangerous to me, especially with poor visibility.... on a bus. Death by dangerous driving would seem appropriate.


Ye I agree
But 2 guys on one scooter no lights and poor visibility even doing 50 they be dead
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 04, 2026, 02:03:11 pm
Hard to conclude that without staging an experiment reconstructing the accident at that speed. What we do know is that the speed limit is the speed limit for a reason. It's completely and utterly reckless for a professional driver in control of a large vehicle to have such disregard for road safety. If that was his habit it was only ever a matter of time before he killed somebody. The extremes of his dangerous driving are not far removed from the joyriders that used to terrorise housing estates up above in Dublin in the 80s. We're talking over 50% in excess of the prescribed limit.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 04, 2026, 03:05:27 pm
We're all speculating without knowing the full facts.  Like, is he a promising footballer or a coach to a kids team?
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 04, 2026, 07:29:32 pm
Rickshaw driver charged over death of woman after concert in Dublin (https://www.rte.ie/news/courts/2026/1104/1598024-court-gabriel-pereira/)

Quote
A rickshaw driver has been charged over the death of a Co Down woman who suffered catastrophic injuries after a concert in Dublin in September.  Gardaí obtained instructions from the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) to charge him with dangerous driving causing the death of Danielle O'Keane, a 37-year-old mother of two from Saval, Newry, Co Down.  Mr Pereira, of Seville Place, Dublin 1, is also accused of endangering the lives of three other women during the same incident on the night of 26 September at North Wall Quay.

... It was alleged that he was in a cycle lane and made a "reckless manoeuvre" trying to leave it and merge into traffic when he struck a concrete bollard on the ground, causing Ms O'Keane to go underneath the carriage and suffer "catastrophic injuries".

... Pleading for bail, counsel described the incident as extremely tragic, submitting, "it is not a case of intent, it is a case of recklessness".

... Opposing bail, Sgt O'Neill cited flight risk concerns, telling the court that the accused came to Ireland eight days before the incident on a travel visa.

Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 04, 2026, 07:37:34 pm
Busy day for driving offences...

Headline says dangerous driving but text says careless driving.

Woman, 87, gets suspended sentence for dangerous driving causing death (https://www.rte.ie/news/munster/2026/1104/1597947-agnes-foley/)

Quote
An 87-year-old woman, who pleaded guilty to careless driving causing the death of a 72-year-old woman and serious injury to a 66-year-old man, has received a suspended sentence of 18 months.  Agnes Foley, from Farran in Charleville, Co Cork, who was 85 at the time, was attempting to park her car on Charleville Main Street on 2 November 2024 when she accidentally put her foot on the accelerator instead of the brake.  The car mounted the footpath and hit two pedestrians, Mary Fehilly, who died in Cork University Hospital (CUH) later that evening, and John Collins, who suffered life-altering injuries.  Ms Foley previously entered a guilty plea to driving without due care causing the death of Ms Fehilly and to a second count driving without due care on the same date, causing serious bodily harm to Mr. Collins.

[lots of mitigation]

In passing sentence, the judge said the offences fall within the category of careless driving, which carries maximum penalty of two years imprisonment.  She imposed a sentence of 18 months imprisonment of each of the two counts to run concurrently. However, based on the mitigating factors, Ms. Justice Boyle said that it was not "necessary or desirable" in this case to have an immediate custodial sentence.  Both sentences were suspended in full for a period of 18 months, on condition that Ms Foley keep the peace and be of good behaviour.  The judge disqualified Ms Foley from driving for five years.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 04, 2026, 07:42:25 pm
87 year olds with driving licences... FFS, what do they expect? NDLS should be done for murder.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: silverbullet on November 04, 2026, 07:49:15 pm
76 kilos/hour in a 50 kilo/hour zone seems pretty dangerous to me, especially with poor visibility.... on a bus. Death by dangerous driving would seem appropriate.


Ye I agree
But 2 guys on one scooter no lights and poor visibility even doing 50 they be dead
Two black guys on one scooter with no lights, at two o'clock at night, all dressed in black, moving erratically. None of us would stand a chance seeing them.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: silverbullet on November 04, 2026, 07:50:25 pm
We're all speculating without knowing the full facts.  Like, is he a promising footballer or a coach to a kids team?
He was a big coach. 8)
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 04, 2026, 08:16:13 pm
The bus did have cameras on board!

CCTV footage of fatal Waterford collision shown to jury (https://www.rte.ie/news/courts/2026/1104/1598028-waterford-collision-court/)

The 15 & 17 yr old went to a gym at 1am in the morning and left an hour later.  On a school night (Thurs) if that makes a difference.

Quote
The moment of collision was captured clearly via onboard dashcam footage from the bus.  This footage showed the two boys veer to the centre of the road, before an immediate shattering of the front windscreen upon impact.... After the collision, the bus drove a short distance before stopping, and Mr Doyle disembarked at approximately 2.03am.

[The bus was in good condition]

... The e-scooter was deemed not road legal, had no visible lights and was above the permitted electrical power threshold, Garda Mernagh said.

... The court was told Mr Doyle was driving 77km/h at the time of the collision, in a 50km/h zone.

Wouldn't surprise me if this wasn't plead down to careless driving or similar.  And/or the jury acquit on the dangerous driving charge.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 04, 2026, 08:19:32 pm
You could be right. I didn't notice it was two black kids. What was he thinking driving a bus at 77 kilos/hour in a 50 zone... I hope he's never allowed drive again.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 05, 2026, 01:05:18 am
You could be right. I didn't notice it was two black kids. What was he thinking driving a bus at 77 kilos/hour in a 50 zone... I hope he's never allowed drive again.

2  kids drivin a black scooter wir no lights wearin black tracksuits in the dark an the bus driver is a cnut ?  ... ill offer a grand bet to any of yuse  virtual signillin cnuts on here  that the bus driver will be vindicated... if indeed the woke fucking madness is excluded from physics and common sense ... yu all  on here care more abou how you appear to the world than dealin wit facts .... wat wer they doin drivin in the middle o the bleedin road wit zero illumination or regard to  road safety ?  They didnt give a fuk bout ther own safety  mostlty due to the arrogance an invincibility  of youth .... all of you encounter this on probly a daily basis ... wedder its a deliveroo goin down the road at 50 kmph lookin at his next curry job  total disregard  or 2 teenagers  drivin in the middle ov the road  in black in the dark wit no regard .... have a bit of compassion  for fuk sake to the bus driver who cud be any  one of us in our taxi at any time and has to live wit killing kids ...
Every fukin topic on here is politisised  .... its fukin sick ... yis are all fukin nut jobs on here ... mad bastards....
 ::sleep
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 05, 2026, 01:25:54 am
 ::sleep
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Taxi driver42 on November 05, 2026, 07:22:59 am
Rickshaw driver charged in connection with death of mum after Westlife gig

https://www.dublinlive.ie/news/rickshaw-driver-charged-connection-death-34863524#ICID=Android_App_DublinLiveAppShare (https://www.dublinlive.ie/news/rickshaw-driver-charged-connection-death-34863524#ICID=Android_App_DublinLiveAppShare)
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 05, 2026, 10:37:09 am
Rickshaw driver charged in connection with death of mum after Westlife gig

https://www.dublinlive.ie/news/rickshaw-driver-charged-connection-death-34863524#ICID=Android_App_DublinLiveAppShare (https://www.dublinlive.ie/news/rickshaw-driver-charged-connection-death-34863524#ICID=Android_App_DublinLiveAppShare)

Should be hanged.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 05, 2026, 10:44:39 am
.... have a bit of compassion  for fuk sake to the bus driver who cud be any  one of us in our taxi at any time and has to live wit killing kids ... ..


It couldn't happen to any of us. It could happen to those of you who are stupid and reckless enough to treat a bus like a Formula One race car with a city street serving as the racetrack in poor visibility. We're talking about a professional driver here following a bus route not a tourist or recent immigrant who might not know the roads or that speed limits are in kilos. It was only a matter of time before the poor man killed someone driving a bus in that manner, lucky for him that it was only two black children when it happened.

I wouldn't be in any hurry to travel on one of those JJ Kavanagh buses if that's the kind of headcase they employ to drive them.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 05, 2026, 11:35:42 am
By the nuts
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 05, 2026, 11:37:53 am
.... have a bit of compassion  for fuk sake to the bus driver who cud be any  one of us in our taxi at any time and has to live wit killing kids ... ..


It couldn't happen to any of us. It could happen to those of you who are stupid and reckless enough to treat a bus like a Formula One race car with a city street serving as the racetrack in poor visibility. We're talking about a professional driver here following a bus route not a tourist or recent immigrant who might not know the roads or that speed limits are in kilos. It was only a matter of time before the poor man killed someone driving a bus in that manner, lucky for him that it was only two black children when it happened.

I wouldn't be in any hurry to travel on one of those JJ Kavanagh buses if that's the kind of headcase they employ to drive them.


String em up ...
 :D
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 10, 2026, 12:12:07 pm
Guilty as charged, m'lud  C:-)

Bus driver guilty of dangerous driving causing deaths of two teenagers (https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2026/1110/1598663-adrian-doyle-court/)

Quote
A 43-year-old bus driver has been found guilty of dangerous driving causing the deaths of two teenagers who were travelling on an e-scooter in Waterford over two years ago.

... He had pleaded not guilty to dangerous driving causing the deaths of the two teenagers.  However, this morning, a jury of nine men and three women at Waterford Circuit Criminal Court returned a unanimous guilty verdict on the charge of dangerous driving causing death after deliberating for a total of three hours and 29 minutes.

Judge Eugene O'Kelly remanded Doyle on continuing bail until 13 January next to fix a date for sentencing.

I'm surprised but, of course, I didn't see all the evidence.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: markmiwurdz on November 10, 2026, 12:14:32 pm
There will surely have to be some bit of culpability on the deceased (RIP),hard and all as it is.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 10, 2026, 12:18:29 pm
I think it was pretty clear cut. Driving in that manner he was always going to kill someone. He should get two life sentences to run consecutively and a driving ban of at least 30 years.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 10, 2026, 01:01:15 pm
There will surely have to be some bit of culpability on the deceased (RIP),hard and all as it is.

I think the argument went something like they came out of left field suddenly and, if the bus driver was doing 50 instead of 70-something, he might have had a chance to avoid them or at least not kill them? 

My sympathy is with the bus driver tbh.  Let those without sin cast the first stone 'n all that...
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 10, 2026, 08:08:40 pm
Stone cast!

I hope they never let that moron behind the wheel of another motor vehicle for the rest of his natural.

... and I hope the poor man's plight may serve as a wake up call for anyone else who habitually disregards the rules of the road, particularly professional drivers. Speed Kills.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 10, 2026, 09:49:07 pm
Yes he was speeding
... but thers a  very good reason why the recent laws came in  wer 2 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a helmet is illegal , being under 18 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a hi- viz  is illegal , not having lights is illegal and wearing black clothes  in the middle of the road  driving with reckless abandon in poor visibility  suicidal and extremely careless without any regard to the danger such is the arrogance and inexperience of youth ... this case  maybe even braut them laws forward ...
Terrible for all concerned  but particularly the driver  who has to live with the memory replayed  that moment everyday for the rest of his life  ....   he is not completely to blame  and should be released without any penalties
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: silverbullet on November 10, 2026, 11:13:00 pm
Yes he was speeding
... but thers a  very good reason why the recent laws came in  wer 2 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a helmet is illegal , being under 18 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a hi- viz  is illegal , not having lights is illegal and wearing black clothes  in the middle of the road  driving with reckless abandon in poor visibility  suicidal and extremely careless without any regard to the danger such is the arrogance and inexperience of youth ... this case  maybe even braut them laws forward ...
Terrible for all concerned  but particularly the driver  who has to live with the memory replayed  that moment everyday for the rest of his life  ....   he is not completely to blame  and should be released without any penalties
The jury were probably virtue signalling. Citing, boys will be boys. etc. Who in their right mind allows their children to visit a gym at 02.00?
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 10, 2026, 11:30:33 pm
Yes he was speeding
... but thers a  very good reason why the recent laws came in  wer 2 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a helmet is illegal , being under 18 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a hi- viz  is illegal , not having lights is illegal and wearing black clothes  in the middle of the road  driving with reckless abandon in poor visibility  suicidal and extremely careless without any regard to the danger such is the arrogance and inexperience of youth ... this case  maybe even braut them laws forward ...
Terrible for all concerned  but particularly the driver  who has to live with the memory replayed  that moment everyday for the rest of his life  ....   he is not completely to blame  and should be released without any penalties
The jury were probably virtue signalling. Citing, boys will be boys. etc. Who in their right mind allows their children to visit a gym at 02.00?


This situation cud happen to any one of us bullits ... we've all come across this situation even by day ... at night  wit almost zero visibility weve no chance .... maybe we got lucky so far ...
Thers a myriad of factors at play here ... common sense from a jury nowadays isnt goin in the drivers favour neither unfortunately nor probable  from the judge ....
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: markmiwurdz on November 11, 2026, 08:49:39 am
Yes he was speeding
... but thers a  very good reason why the recent laws came in  wer 2 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a helmet is illegal , being under 18 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a hi- viz  is illegal , not having lights is illegal and wearing black clothes  in the middle of the road  driving with reckless abandon in poor visibility  suicidal and extremely careless without any regard to the danger such is the arrogance and inexperience of youth ... this case  maybe even braut them laws forward ...
Terrible for all concerned  but particularly the driver  who has to live with the memory replayed  that moment everyday for the rest of his life  ....   he is not completely to blame  and should be released without any penalties
The jury were probably virtue signalling. Citing, boys will be boys. etc. Who in their right mind allows their children to visit a gym at 02.00?


This situation cud happen to any one of us bullits ... we've all come across this situation even by day ... at night  wit almost zero visibility weve no chance .... maybe we got lucky so far ...
Thers a myriad of factors at play here ... common sense from a jury nowadays isnt goin in the drivers favour neither unfortunately nor probable  from the judge ....

Was driving in Monkstown about 3am a few years back,really dark out and heading back in empty,cyclist on my side of the road in dark clothes cylcying TOWARDS  me with headphones on and not holding the handlebars totally obliviouis to the danger they were in.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 11, 2026, 08:57:34 am
Were you exceeding the speed limit by more than 50% in a bus?
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 11, 2026, 08:58:24 am
Yes he was speeding
... but thers a  very good reason why the recent laws came in  wer 2 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a helmet is illegal , being under 18 on a scooter is illegal , not wearin a hi- viz  is illegal , not having lights is illegal and wearing black clothes  in the middle of the road  driving with reckless abandon in poor visibility  suicidal and extremely careless without any regard to the danger such is the arrogance and inexperience of youth ... this case  maybe even braut them laws forward ...
Terrible for all concerned  but particularly the driver  who has to live with the memory replayed  that moment everyday for the rest of his life  ....   he is not completely to blame  and should be released without any penalties
The jury were probably virtue signalling. Citing, boys will be boys. etc. Who in their right mind allows their children to visit a gym at 02.00?


This situation cud happen to any one of us bullits ... we've all come across this situation even by day ... at night  wit almost zero visibility weve no chance .... maybe we got lucky so far ...
Thers a myriad of factors at play here ... common sense from a jury nowadays isnt goin in the drivers favour neither unfortunately nor probable  from the judge ....

It couldn't happen to any of us. It could happen to those of you who are stupid and reckless enough to treat a bus like a Formula One race car with a city street serving as the racetrack in poor visibility. We're talking about a professional driver here following a bus route not a tourist or recent immigrant who might not know the roads or that speed limits are in kilos. It was only a matter of time before the poor man killed someone driving a bus in that manner.

I wouldn't be in any hurry to travel on one of those JJ Kavanagh buses if that's the kind of headcase they employ to drive them.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: mercenary for hire on November 11, 2026, 09:56:48 am
Speeding seems to be tolerated in Ireland until you kill someone.You have to wonder why the driver was in such a hurry if he's on a salary.Are these lads under pressure from their bosses?

The way some coach drivers push through town sometimes you'd swear they were getting bonuses for being on time.

One thing that I remember from the news on this case was the marks on the bus windscreen from the victims.

If the scooter was doing 20km and the bus was hitting 76km that's a massive difference. The driver of the bus might have only severely injured the lads if he was at the 50 limit.I don't always fixate on the limits but driving a coach is another level of responsibility.

The blame here is down to authorities for not enforcing the limits and for not being more aggressive in policing the leccy scooters.A lot of similarities to the Rickshaw situation in another thread.Even the Uber eats and deliveroo lads still have no lights and they're on the road as part of their job. No enforcement is the main reason for a lot of these deaths.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 11, 2026, 10:44:41 am
Watty noted that we likely don't have all the facts that were available to the jury. He also fixates to some degree on the scooter moving to the right but skips over the bus also moving to the right. The scooter was at the centre line of the road at the point of impact and was struck by the centre point of the bus so the bus was clearly well over the centre line of the road. The fact that the scooter was visible on the dashcam footage shows that it was visible to the driver. We don't know what caused both to move to the right... was there an obstruction on the road, was there a right turn coming up that the scooter intended taking, etc... we do know that the driver made no attempt to hit the brakes and we all know that his instinctive escape route would have been to move the bus to the left not the right. Maybe road rage was a factor?
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: mercenary for hire on November 11, 2026, 10:58:46 am
It's possible the scooter moved to the right lane as they realised they couldn't get out of the way fast enough and the bus also did the same thing to avoid them and disaster followed.At 76kmph there not much time.

There's a lot of kids in my area and they clearly have no idea which part of the road is the right part for a slow moving vehicle.

In the last few years I've had at least three situations where the electric scooter or e bike was on the wrong side of the road coming towards me. Lucky for them my brakes are good but I dunno if slamming on the brakes in a coach would be my first instinct especially with passengers on board.Hard to know.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 11, 2026, 11:02:21 am
 oops
Watty noted that we likely don't have all the facts that were available to the jury. He also fixates to some degree on the scooter moving to the right but skips over the bus also moving to the right. The scooter was at the centre line of the road at the point of impact and was struck by the centre point of the bus so the bus was clearly well over the centre line of the road. The fact that the scooter was visible on the dashcam footage shows that it was visible to the driver. We don't know what caused both to move to the right... was there an obstruction on the road, was there a right turn coming up that the scooter intended taking, etc... we do know that the driver made no attempt to hit the brakes and we all know that his instinctive escape route would have been to move the bus to the left not the right. Maybe road rage was a factor?



Yea ... string the   far rite cunt up .... its obvious he cud see in the dark  they wer  nig nogs  an murdered them ... the dirty  facist racist  bastardin cnut ...  ..... sell his gaff  an giv the money ta queers for palastine , climate action an  to the congo  in reparation for slavery ... an some ta greta .....

 Im a lovely bloke ... ahem ... clears throat  an sticks tung in cheek







 ::sleep
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 11, 2026, 11:02:53 am
Aaah... the old driving instructor question.... There's an old woman on a mobility scooter on the left of the road and two black kids on an eScooter on the right of the road... what do you hit?

A. The brakes... Your instinct must always be to hit the brakes!
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: mercenary for hire on November 11, 2026, 11:07:33 am
So even if it's a large vehicle with a longer braking distance the advice is still to slam on hard rather than swerve to avoid?

I've never driven a bus but on the motorbike you'd try to go round where possible as hard braking isn't always the safest bet..
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: markmiwurdz on November 11, 2026, 11:11:19 am
Were you exceeding the speed limit by more than 50% in a bus?

You're missing the point,nobody denies the driver was way more to blame by speeding but the deceased didn't help themselves in the lead up to the crash and would have been seriously injured and possiblty still killed if he was driving at the correct speed.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 11, 2026, 11:20:36 am
A motorcycle is a hell of a lot easier to steer at speed and requires less space to safely navigate any obstacle than is the case for a LPSV. Where impact is imminent and unavoidable - albeit in this case due to hugely excessive speed - attempting an emergency stop is the only option and is something drivers are trained to execute. Also, whatever caused both vehicles to move to the right - in the case of the bus, crossing the centre line of the road - probably should have also caused the drivers to reduce speed. Less space = Less pace!

I'm not missing that point at all, MMW... but to suggest that serious injury or death would have resulted regardless of the bus being driven in an extremely dangerous manner takes us into the realms of speculation and, as such, is largely irrelevant. The moron driving the bus was always going to kill someone driving in that manner. We could say it's lucky he didn't end up killing an entire bus load of passengers before his absolute incompetence resulted in the inevitable. He shouldn't be allowed behind the wheel of another motor vehicle as long as he lives.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 11, 2026, 11:30:08 am

(https://i.postimg.cc/wMSGQskR/images-(33).jpg) (https://postimages.org/)


Burn the cnut
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 11, 2026, 11:30:30 am
Rat ... yur a bleedin nut job

 ::sleep
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 11, 2026, 12:25:23 pm
He's only winding youse up.

We live in a country where learner drivers are forbidden to drive on a motorway but 5 seconds after getting their licence, away they go at 120 km/hr on the motorway!  And how many years did it take before the crackdown on repeat learner permits and unaccompanied driving? 

As the old joke goes, the rules of the road are not rules, only suggestions.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Octavia1 on November 11, 2026, 02:33:47 pm
He's only winding youse up.

We live in a country where learner drivers are forbidden to drive on a motorway but 5 seconds after getting their licence, away they go at 120 km/hr on the motorway!  And how many years did it take before the crackdown on repeat learner permits and unaccompanied driving? 

As the old joke goes, the rules of the road are not rules, only suggestions.

Hes a nawful  winder upper alrite .... cud be a closeted  far rite  the cnut  ::fds
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 12, 2026, 01:51:09 pm
Driving at 120 kilos/hour on a motorway is quite different to driving at c.80 kilos/hour on a road shared with non motorised traffic in an urban setting. We have speed limits for a reason and those of you who actually would drive a bus in such a dangerous manner need to have a long hard think about why you would do that. You are essentially turning that bus into a murder weapon.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: silverbullet on November 12, 2026, 02:40:52 pm
Driving at 120 kilos/hour on a motorway is quite different to driving at c.80 kilos/hour on a road shared with non motorised traffic in an urban setting. We have speed limits for a reason and those of you who actually would drive a bus in such a dangerous manner need to have a long hard think about why you would do that. You are essentially turning that bus into a murder weapon.
Those bus drivers are under considerable pressure from the company owners, who should be held equally liable.
We have all experienced aggressive driving by Aircoach drivers, J.J.Kavanagh drivers are no different.

Dashcams should be mandatory. Video evidence should be available to monitor the behaviour of E-scooters/E-bike riders. Those riders in the tragic case in the O.P. should be apportioned a fair degree of blame for their own demise.

Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: mercenary for hire on November 12, 2026, 03:05:58 pm
In fairness the tech exists to limit speeds on these vehicles. You have to wonder why it's not already present.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: silverbullet on November 12, 2026, 06:55:26 pm
In fairness the tech exists to limit speeds on these vehicles. You have to wonder why it's not already present.
In Ireland, the maximum speed of a bus or coach fitted with an electronic speed limiter depends on the vehicle type and design:
• Buses / Coaches designed for seated passengers only (M2/M3): Speed limiters are legally required to be set to a maximum of 100 km/h (approx. 62 mph).
• City-type / Urban buses designed or adapted to carry standing passengers (single or double-deck): They are typically electronically limited or restricted by traffic regulations to a maximum of 65 km/h.

Perhaps someone has tampered with the tachograph, and or limiter?
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 13, 2026, 10:45:24 am
I think it was an airport bus so it would be permitted to travel at speeds of up to 100 kilos/hour on motorways. The limiting devices generally aren't dynamic, perhaps with modern technology they could be but really it's up to drivers to observe the rules of the road. Driving in the manner that the driver was in this case was only ever going to end in death.
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 15, 2026, 03:00:47 pm
I wonder if he was going too fast or too slow?

Man held after allegedly pulling fake gun on bus driver (https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2026/1115/1599280-cork-bus-hijacking/)

Quote
Gardaí have arrested a man after he allegedly used an imitation firearm and threatened the driver of a bus travelling from Dublin Airport to Cork.

The coach, with around a dozen people on board, had left Dublin Airport in the early hours of Saturday morning.  As the bus travelled close to Kilworth on the M8 motorway in north Cork, the man is alleged to have pulled an imitation firearm on the driver and made a number of threats.  However, he was overpowered by a number of other passengers.

The bus was stopped at the M8 toll plaza at Watergrasshill in Cork and gardaí were contacted.  In a statement, gardaí say they arrested a man in his 30s at the scene.

Who knew rural bus driving could be so exciting!
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: silverbullet on November 15, 2026, 06:16:40 pm
I wonder if he was going too fast or too slow?

Man held after allegedly pulling fake gun on bus driver (https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2026/1115/1599280-cork-bus-hijacking/)

Quote
Gardaí have arrested a man after he allegedly used an imitation firearm and threatened the driver of a bus travelling from Dublin Airport to Cork.

The coach, with around a dozen people on board, had left Dublin Airport in the early hours of Saturday morning.  As the bus travelled close to Kilworth on the M8 motorway in north Cork, the man is alleged to have pulled an imitation firearm on the driver and made a number of threats.  However, he was overpowered by a number of other passengers.

The bus was stopped at the M8 toll plaza at Watergrasshill in Cork and gardaí were contacted.  In a statement, gardaí say they arrested a man in his 30s at the scene.

Who knew rural bus driving could be so exciting!
I remember that happened in Dublin. Two attackers went into the bus garage in Summerhill and tried to hijack a 27b to Kilmore West.

They couldn't find one, instead they hijacked the 27 to Artane roundabout and walked the rest of the way. 8)
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: watty on November 16, 2026, 03:07:29 pm
The fake gun guy (from Belfast) was up in court (https://www.rte.ie/news/courts/2026/1116/1599405-man-who-produced-fake-gun-on-bus-appears-in-court/) and "...added that he wanted to be arrested by Gardaí so he could have somewhere to sleep, and that producing the imitation firearm was "just a wee spur of the moment thing".

They're made of different stuff up North  :-\
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: silverbullet on November 16, 2026, 03:19:58 pm
The fake gun guy (from Belfast) was up in court (https://www.rte.ie/news/courts/2026/1116/1599405-man-who-produced-fake-gun-on-bus-appears-in-court/) and "...added that he wanted to be arrested by Gardaí so he could have somewhere to sleep, and that producing the imitation firearm was "just a wee spur of the moment thing".

They're made of different stuff up North  :-\
This case was successfully argued that the gun was imitation, although it was never found.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-northern-ireland-66750123 (https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-northern-ireland-66750123)
Title: Re: Tragedy involving e-scooter
Post by: Rat Catcher on November 16, 2026, 03:36:34 pm
He was taking the traditional route anyway.