Irish Taxi Forum
Public Area => Taxi Talk => Topic started by: Rat Catcher on November 11, 2026, 09:10:34 am
-
The following was posted in the members lounge. I'm not sure if the poster is an ITDF member or whether it is an official ITDF statement or something that has just been scraped from a discussion on social media.
--"Statement"--
382 submissions so far. We need thousands more.
The three NTA public consultations could bring some of the biggest changes our taxi industry has faced in years.
These are not minor changes. They will affect the vehicles we can drive, the costs of staying in business, our regulated fares and the way multinational booking companies operate within our industry.
With approximately 17,575 taxis operating across Ireland, we should be seeing thousands of submissions.
So far:
Decarbonisation – 194 submissions
Dispatch Operator Regulations – 128 submissions
Signage and Advertising – 60 submissions
Total – 382
Decarbonisation is clearly attracting the most attention, and rightly so. The proposed changes will have major consequences for drivers replacing their vehicles in the coming years.
We are looking at vehicle change fees potentially increasing from €150 to €1,000 for certain vehicles, restrictions on what cars drivers can purchase and further financial pressures on wheelchair accessible taxi licence holders.
But the dispatch operator consultation is just as important.
Our €3 booking fee is under threat.
The NTA proposals could allow dispatch operators to take part or potentially all of the driver's €3 booking fee through their own booking charges.
We strongly oppose this. That €3 belongs with the working taxi driver. We do not want technology fees, priority charges or other app charges taking away from it.
There is also the serious issue of fixed pricing. The NTA consultation refers to preventing parallel, unregulated taxi pricing systems, yet the draft regulations do not clearly address the fixed-price arrangements already being operated by booking apps.
We will be challenging this and defending the regulated taxi meter and fare structure.
The Irish Taxi Drivers’ Federation, NPHTA and TTNH are currently working together on a joint submission to the NTA.
We are working taxi drivers ourselves. We are out there every day, dealing with the costs, the hours, the vehicle requirements and everything else that goes with earning a living in this industry.
We understand what these changes mean because we are the people who will have to live with them.
We have an industry full of experienced drivers with enormous knowledge and plenty of good opinions. Now is the time to make those opinions heard.
Remember, the big multinational companies such as FREENOW, Uber and Bolt have the same opportunity to make submissions and protect their business interests.
We need drivers protecting theirs.
Please, if you haven't made a submission, take the time to do it.
If you know another driver who isn't comfortable with online forms, help them. Sit down with them and help them put their own views forward.
Share these consultations in your WhatsApp groups, with drivers on the ranks and with family and friends.
These are public consultations. Passengers and members of the public can also have their say.
You don't need to be a legal expert. You don't need pages of arguments. Your experience as a working taxi driver is what matters.
THE THREE NTA CONSULTATIONS
1. Decarbonisation
https://consult.nationaltransport.ie/en/node/25665
2. Dispatch Operator Regulations
https://consult.nationaltransport.ie/en/node/25666
3. Signage and Advertising
https://consult.nationaltransport.ie/.../spsv-signage...
These are still proposals, not final regulations. This is our opportunity to influence what happens next.
The Federation and our fellow driver representative organisations will continue to defend the interests of working taxi drivers.
But we need the industry behind us.
17,575 taxis. Just 382 submissions so far.
-
Insofar as it encourages drivers' to engage with the review process, I agree wholeheartedly. Obviously we are at the final "Public Consultation" stage of the process now and what we have has already taken submissions to earlier phases into account so I'm not suggesting that your opinion matters to NTA as far as the current review process is concerned or that anything of substance will be changed at this stage. In fact, I'm of the firm belief (based on decades experience of contributing to similar processes) that nothing of substance will be changed at this juncture.
However, I always find that making a submission is a useful tool in jotting down what you might like and what you might dislike about the reforms. That can help focus minds on where there might be scope for future gains or protections for drivers on foot of future engagement and can serve as a useful point of reference for those minded to engage in political lobbying going forward.
My own approach, that I intend to conduct on this very forum and within this very thread, is to start by jotting down points of note and what positives and negatives may be considered under each heading with the ultimate objective upon further consideration and review of producing something that fits my own personal perspective together with what I believe might be beneficial to the trade as a whole. Obviously, totality is an important concept to consider. Ultimately, regardless of personal circumstances a heathy trade for all is a healthy trade for all hence it's sometimes beneficial to consider the concept of no pain, no gain in arriving at a rational conclusion.
There's no need to rush into any of it. It's better to spend some time rationalising your thoughts than to rushing into getting it off the TODO list. The closing dates for submissions are as follows:
SPSV Signage, Displays and Advertising Consultation ( https://consult.nationaltransport.ie/en/consultation/spsv-signage-displays-and-advertising-consultation ) = 04 December 2026
SPSV Decarbonisation Consultation ( https://consult.nationaltransport.ie/en/node/25665 ) = 04 December 2026
SPSV Dispatch Operator Consultation ( https://consult.nationaltransport.ie/en/node/25666 ) = 18 December 2026
-
In considering my own submission to SPSV Sinage, Displays and Advertising Consultation I have noted the following:
Ban on advertising non-SPSV services on SPSVs
Positive
- No more Uber Eats adverts on taxis.
Negative
- Drivers lose a (potential) source of revenue.
Removal of area stickers from roof signs
Not hugely significant in itself but the rationale behind it gives some insight into NTAs thinking as far as restricting the drivers of taxis that are licensed to operate nationwide to arbitrary regions as far as standing and plying for hire goes. What is beyond dispute is that advances in technology have introduced a regime within which drivers of public hire vehicles now customarily serve the private hire market outside of the areas within which they may be licensed to ply and stand for hire. Extending my thoughts into the realms of speculative extrapolation I'm minded to conclude that there is a reasonable case for removing area restrictions from SPSV driving licences and that doing so could serve to level the playing field between drivers of public hire vehicles and drivers of private hire vehicles. Such a strategy could also serve to recognise the expansion of commuter belts in recent times. Many drivers who are licenced to ply and stand for hire in Dublin, for example, now live in adjoining counties. Allowing those drivers (commence) work from their local taxi rank - where such a facility exists - would serve to enhance driver productivity and would reduce dead kilometreage which would be hugely beneficial to the environment and could reduce reliance on the public EV charging infrastructure where such drivers operate ZEVs.
Positives
- Good for drivers who customarily straddle county borders.
- Potential to open the lucrative city ranks to rural drivers. Good for rural drivers, good for supply in cities at peak times.
Negatives
- Potential to open the lucrative city ranks to rural drivers. Bad for city drivers, bad for supply in rural areas at peak times.
- Drivers who have purchased stickers in recent times will feel that they have been scammed. NTA could mitigate such negative goodwill by offering full refunds to drivers who have purchased the stickers within the last year or two.
Dispatch Operator Branding on Limousines
As far as the current review process goes this represents the biggest threat to the taxi trade going forward as it clearly represents the introduction of "proper" Uber through the back door. Speculative extrapolation leads me to believe that this is just the start. The next step will be lifting the current temporary moratorium on the issue of saloon hackney plates, perhaps limited to ZEVs to further NTAs decarbonisation programme.
Positives
There are none.
Negatives
- Branded limousines will become the modern day equivalent of hackneys with ping pong balls on their aerials. They will ply for hire and they will charge riders extortionate fares at peak times in the big cities.
- Fake branded limousines will be a lot easier to produce than fake taxis currently are. This represents a real danger to the public that ought to be taken seriously, particularly given that NTA enforcement officers have no statutory powers to police unlicensed services.
-
In considering my own submission to the SPSV Decarbonisation Consultation I have noted the following:
Changes to Age rules
- 7yr rule for saloon cars, 12yr rule for WAVs
For saloon cars the lowered age limit only applies to non-ZEVs first licensed in 2028. Easily avoidable by changing the car in 2027.
For WAVs the lowered limit will apply to non-ZEVs/PHEVs first licensed from 2028 onward. Lowered limit is still higher than existing limit that applies to saloon vehicles hence there's not a whole lot to get excited about.
For legacy WAVs age limits will apply which subject those 48 vehicles to the same rules as apply to everyone else. Again no big deal unless you happen to own one or some of those plates and you feel that you should be treated as a special person with special needs.
Positive
- slight improvement to minimum standards as far as quality goes with some safety relevant improvements as safety related systems fitted to motor vehicles typically improve as time progresses.
Negative
- very slight increase to the cost of operating a WA taxi or hackney licence caused by more frequent changes of vehicle where a fossil fuel car is chosen.
Removal of Fossil Fuel cars from the saloon fleet
- from 2029 only ZEVs will be first licensed
Positives
- Good for the environment
- Potential improvements to safety as EVs typically require specialist servicing so ought to be more likely to be maintained to manufacturer specification than fossil fuel cars that may be subject to less stringent practices employed by back street garages or DIY repairs and maintenance.
- Reduced fuel costs for drivers who have access to home charging facilities.
- Feelgood factor for drivers who believe that they are saving the planet by using cars that are powered by electricity that is generated from burning fossil fuels as opposed to the more fuel efficient traditional engines that burn fossil fuels directly with no power factor or electricity generation/distribution losses.
Negatives
- Bad for the environment. Using fossil fuel to generate and distribute electricity to power motor vehicles is considerably less efficient than powering vehicles directly with fossil fuels and the vehicles themselves weigh significantly more than equivalent fossil fuel powered vehicles. Basic physics tells us that it takes more energy to move more weight.
- Potential fire safety issues given that lithium batteries and the charging thereof has been identified as being quite high on the list of causes of house fires. If charging the battery of a little 12 year old mobile phone can burn a house down one can only imagine what damage EV batteries and the charging thereof may cause as they age.
- Increased traffic congestion. When an EV breaks down it typically becomes an immovable object which generally can't be simply pushed out of the way as is the case with a fossil fuel vehicle.
- Increased stress on the national grid. Creating incremental demand for electricity obviously increases whatever potential for shortages on the supply side might exist or might materialise due to circumstances beyond the control of the Irish authorities. In particular such demand could contribute to reducing supplies available to essential infrastructure such as data centres.
- Increased vehicle maintenance costs for drivers. Servicing of EVs is typically restricted to main dealers and specialist workshops which charge considerably higher rates than applicable to fossil fuel vehicles.
Increased licensing fees
In itself pretty insignificant as the increase of up to €875 only applies to first licensing of vehicles that run on fossil fuel. In the case of saloon vehicles it is easily avoided by changing the car in 2027 instead of 2028.
However, the concept of applying different fees to different circumstances as a tool to encourage the desired move to ZEVs is an interesting one and one that could have further potential. I intend to have a look at the 5 or 6 biggest MPOs to see how the proportion of EVs on their fleets compares to the entire fleet of licenced taxis. My thinking is that it could be beneficial to consider lifting the current temporary moratorium on the issue of saloon taxi plates in respect of EVs only with annual licence renewal fees set at a rate that would be considerably higher than applicable to the existing fleet but would equate to offering drivers a, perhaps marginally, cheaper alternative to being stuck in the rental market. Funds raised through such a scheme could be ringfenced to financing the provision of grant aided ZEV WA taxis. Such a scheme may also serve to make the trade more attractive to younger men.
Positives
- may encourage owners of WA vehicles to minimise the frequency of vehicle changes which has obvious environmental benefits.
- may encourage owners of WA vehicles to consider purchasing ZEVs or PHEVs.
Negative
- slightly increased overheads for drivers who refuse to provide ZEWAVs or PHEWAVs.
Grant Aid
NTA states that grant aid in respect of saloon ZEVs is determined by DoT so any phasing out is beyond it's control. Given the shambolic manner in which eSPSV26 was administered by NTA it is clear that DoT ought to be lobbied to find a competent organisation to administer any future schemes.
NTA states that it will continue to devise, administer and control WAV grant aid schemes going forward and suggests that from 2027 grant aid under those schemes will be focussed on the provision of ZEWAVs and PHEWAVs. That seems reasonable given that there has been scant interest in providing ZEWAVs or PHEWAVs to date. However, NTA justifies it's decision to restrict all first licensed saloon taxis and hackneys to ZEVs from 2029 by drawing refence to the fact that TfL restricted all first licenced taxis to ZEVs way back in 2018. London taxis are all WAVs which obviously calls into question why WAVs should enjoy exemption from the rules applicable to saloon taxis in this jurisdiction.
I would suggest that allocation of future grant aid should be focussed on existing participants, both owners of current WAV licences and drivers who have been forced into the rental market, in the first instance. Such focus could serve to attract younger men to the trade as it would serve to provide an avenue to progression.
Positive
- Grant aid is great for drivers who get it as it gives them a significant competitive edge over those who don't.
Negatives
- Grant aid puts those drivers whose applications for the same are unsuccessful at a considerable competitive disadvantage.
Dublin Airport Taxi Ranks
Taxi ranks at Dublin Airport are operated and controlled by Dublin Airport Authority. For some reason DAA remains the only authority in Ireland that is allowed regulate it's taxi services on a quantitative basis.
I recently hired a taxi from the rank at Dublin Airport and upon my travelling companion suggesting to the rank marshal that she'd prefer not to travel in the 15 year old converted cargo vehicle that was first in line we were directed to a clapped out 9 year old Toyota Prius. My travelling companion asked why I - as the owner driver of a brand new 2026 EV - don't work from that rank and was completely mystified to learn that I am not allowed. If this doesn't highlight the urgent need to implement qualitative rather than quantitative restrictions I don't know what will. If we look at airport taxi ranks around the world we are often met with choices between EVs or fossil fuel vehicles (e.g. Krakow which operates two distinct ranks) yet we are still greeting our international visitors with a third world service. Obviously, qualitative regulation would incentivise drivers to provide newer cars which would, in turn, accelerate NTAs decarbonisation programme.
-
I'd be wary of suggesting measures that would increase our operating costs for a few reasons.
One is that there's plenty of men out there living in 'bedsits', maybe divorced, living week-to-week with rent and maybe support payments. They can't afford to put aside a few hundred a week to pay for a shiny new EV.
Second is the anomaly (to me) that the NTA hires expensive consultants every two years to figure out our operating costs etc with the aim of regulating the fare structure and then is immediately undercut by the apps. It's a bit silly that the NTA says we need X to survive and operate and the apps say "actually it'll be X-30% and we'll keep the difference."
Thirdly, I wouldn't be surprised if there was a worldwide recession in the next few years so it's make sense (to me) to keep our heads down and not be spending the big bucks.
My 3c ;D
-
If EU change their policy on Chinese EVs were all stuck overpaying for more expensive and possibly more unreliable Euro variants.In the absence of grants I wouldn't touch an EV with a barge pole.Chinese or not.
Difficulty in sourcing parts has been a huge issue for some forum members.Expensive servicing is another factor.Electricity is no longer cheap so that's not an advantage anymore.
EVs are only acceptable while the grants are generous and business is ok. As soon as things deteriorate in the economy we will need to drive almost twice kilometres for the same money.Why would we want to financially handcuff ourselves to EVs?.
Madness lads. Tell the NTA to go and fuk themselves.
No need to put this in the submission RC.
-
By the way just to add no other sector of our economy are 100% EVs.
The cops don't use them 100%.
No electric fire engines or ambulances still.
Government limos are still Audi diesels.
Dublin Bus still are not fully electric.Bus Eireann have none as far as I know.
Predicted blackouts due to electricity shortages over the next few years would have all EVs parked up and unusable.
Where is this EV bullshit coming from? Doesn't add up.
I drive one but they're not as usable as a regular vehicle.
-
Why is there no policy to roll out EV chargers .Mursheen Gillacuddy in Down the Country where there are only ten Street lights in the whole of his village has nowhere to charge his new BYD as he lives above Kennys Butcher Shop on the Main Street beside Delaneys Undertakers .Once again Cart before Horse push for more EVs but no infrastructure to charge .
Me Personally I wouldnt change a thing Force a few thousand drivers out of the business .We use to claim there were too many Drivers to many Double Jobbers .Reduce the amount of cars on the road,scarcity will prevent the Apps from Gouging Drivers if they want their Workload covered .
-
Why is there no policy to roll out EV chargers .Mursheen Gillacuddy in Down the Country where there are only ten Street lights in the whole of his village has nowhere to charge his new BYD as he lives above Kennys Butcher Shop on the Main Street beside Delaneys Undertakers .Once again Cart before Horse push for more EVs but no infrastructure to charge .
Me Personally I wouldnt change a thing Force a few thousand drivers out of the business .We use to claim there were too many Drivers to many Double Jobbers .Reduce the amount of cars on the road,scarcity will prevent the Apps from Gouging Drivers if they want their Workload covered .
Are you conceding that private companies with a profit motive (aka the apps) will be the de facto link between us and the passengers?
And the apps could turn it on its head by banning us off the apps if we didn't do enough Ubers/day or Lyfts/day. They could be selective - a few hundred here, a few hundred there. Individual drivers would get the message - Big Brother is watching you ::fds
-
Watty YOUR reps told the Committee they did not want tha apps to be allowed add on extra charges like Booking or teck fees .THEY conseded that Commercial Apps had a role in our industry not me .I was not invited to address the Comittee .When I stood up in the Transport Club many years ago and said make this political the lads told me to fuck off and drove down to invade the Regs Offices .The Constituency I suggested Was Dublin South Central .There are 3 Council areas Drimnagh /Crumlin .Ballyfermor drimnagh and Dublin South City .We did not need to get anybody elected although Councillor Shepard a taxi driver succeeded in the City .All we needed to do was prove we could organise stand togeather .In that Constituency they have Returned 2 Shinners I green i Socialist I marxist .It was wide open for a challenge .The Greens when I made my Suggestion had 4 Councillors Country wide and NO TDs .Look how success full the Greens were in getting what they wanted Bike lanes Taxi Grants for us to save the Planet .Our idea of organising is blocking streets and annoying our own customers and Stickers .I suggested we should be looking for for an App as infrastructure not a Commercial thing when it was first mooted but some people were interested in promoting an app to Settle old scores with Millionair Irish Dispatchers .WHO ASKED FOR THIS REVIEW and DRIVERS WILL GET WHAT THEY DESERVE.
-
Why is there no policy to roll out EV chargers .Mursheen Gillacuddy in Down the Country where there are only ten Street lights in the whole of his village has nowhere to charge his new BYD as he lives above Kennys Butcher Shop on the Main Street beside Delaneys Undertakers .Once again Cart before Horse push for more EVs but no infrastructure to charge .
Me Personally I wouldnt change a thing Force a few thousand drivers out of the business .We use to claim there were too many Drivers to many Double Jobbers .Reduce the amount of cars on the road,scarcity will prevent the Apps from Gouging Drivers if they want their Workload covered .
Thats almost certain .But if they dont have the drivers to cover the work they cannot do that Supply and demand .
Are you conceding that private companies with a profit motive (aka the apps) will be the de facto link between us and the passengers?
And the apps could turn it on its head by banning us off the apps if we didn't do enough Ubers/day or Lyfts/day. They could be selective - a few hundred here, a few hundred there. Individual drivers would get the message - Big Brother is watching you ::fds
-
I'd imagine the apps only have a shortage at weekend nights when drivers deliberately turn off the apps. During the day, jobs are snatched in seconds by drivers. Ban a few hundred and the wait time for passengers might be 5 mins instead of 4. Someone make a joke on here one time that we arrive at people's houses quicker than the emergency services...
-
I'd imagine the apps only have a shortage at weekend nights when drivers deliberately turn off the apps. During the day, jobs are snatched in seconds by drivers. Ban a few hundred and the wait time for passengers might be 5 mins instead of 4. Someone make a joke on here one time that we arrive at people's houses quicker than the emergency services...
The New New taxi DRIVER works for hourly rate he will cover a job for 4 euro if it adds to his hourly takings .Thats the industry now .Its not the industry of TAXIMEN .People who knew their way around and could smell a job miles away .Who knew house parties or GAA clubs with events if there was a local funeral he hovered .People were happy to see him looking after them .That day is gone ..Some lads invested big money into this game old boys who bought expensive plates or lads who ponied up wedge for WATS thinking the Streets of Dublin were paved in Coin only to find after they repay the family and the Plane fare they cannot even afford to turn on the heat in the van as they sleep .The Gig is Up Frankie told us years ago .
-
I'd be wary of suggesting measures that would increase our operating costs for a few reasons.
One is that there's plenty of men out there living in 'bedsits', maybe divorced, living week-to-week with rent and maybe support payments. They can't afford to put aside a few hundred a week to pay for a shiny new EV.
Second is the anomaly (to me) that the NTA hires expensive consultants every two years to figure out our operating costs etc with the aim of regulating the fare structure and then is immediately undercut by the apps. It's a bit silly that the NTA says we need X to survive and operate and the apps say "actually it'll be X-30% and we'll keep the difference."
Thirdly, I wouldn't be surprised if there was a worldwide recession in the next few years so it's make sense (to me) to keep our heads down and not be spending the big bucks.
My 3c ;D
I don't think I've suggested extra costs. On the contrary I think lifting the current temporary moratorium on the issue of saloon plates in respect of EVs would serve to reduce costs for drivers currently trapped in the rental market.... although I do think that any such plates should have annual renewal fees in the region of €5,000 as that is what post-entry liberalisation plates are currently fetching on the rental market.
I haven't made any argument against the increased change of vehicle fees as I don't think it's significant... over 12 years it's less than a ton a year. However, that's not my suggestion, that's what NTA has already decided. Perhaps, if the rules dictating a 100% ZEV saloon fleet by 2037 are extended, it could be a reasonable compromise to increase the annual renewal fee for non-ZEV saloon vehicle licences to €1,000 as a gentler nudge in that direction? Of course, we are well used to vehicle age/standard rules being amended at a whim so that's not something that shouldn't be ruled out going forward, I guess.
The clever people who set the maximum rate permitted by law as calculated by the taximeter are clever enough to know that it can only work on a global basis as a maximum. I might have mentioned before that I recently covered a fare from King St North up above in Dublin to Dublin Airport in respect of which the meter determined that the maximum I was entitled to be paid was less than €29 before commission and other expenses for 38 minutes work including run in. I covered another fare from Stamullen to Dublin Airport and the meter determined that I was entitled to c.€73 for that job which took 32 minutes including run in. I do intend considering fares and commission in more detail in compiling my response to the Dispatch Operator Consultation document but I do think it is important that men and smaller firms retain the right to set their own rates within the parameters set by the clever people who determine what the maximum fare permitted by law as calculated by the taximeter should be. Obviously the ability to introduce special offers or lower rates to stimulate demand becomes more important in recessionary times.
I take your point regarding the men living in bedsits. I did skip over NTA suggesting that those men will be able to switch to fossil fuel powered WAVs if EVs don't suit their circumstances. However, NTA (conveniently?) skipped over what might be a far more attractive proposition to those men i.e. the option of driving a clapped out shitebox plated as a limousine and covered in Uber stickers.
-
If EU change their policy on Chinese EVs were all stuck overpaying for more expensive and possibly more unreliable Euro variants.In the absence of grants I wouldn't touch an EV with a barge pole.Chinese or not.
Difficulty in sourcing parts has been a huge issue for some forum members.Expensive servicing is another factor.Electricity is no longer cheap so that's not an advantage anymore.
EVs are only acceptable while the grants are generous and business is ok. As soon as things deteriorate in the economy we will need to drive almost twice kilometres for the same money.Why would we want to financially handcuff ourselves to EVs?.
Madness lads. Tell the NTA to go and fuk themselves.
No need to put this in the submission RC.
You've certainly identified a lot of negatives to the transition to a 100% ZEV Saloon fleet by 2037 and I take those points on board. I think what's most notable in your thoughts is that the men who have already purchased heavily subsidised EVs are likely just as opposed to EVs becoming compulsory going forward as men who still drive fossil fuel vehicles. In my own case I, like you, would never have considered an EV at full market price.
On reading the new rules I resigned myself to the fact that I will never own another diesel car again. That was a sad day and it was a sad day that immediately followed another equally sad day when, upon reading the Signs and Stickers consultation document, I resigned myself to the fact that I will never get to use the area stickers I recently purchased with the intention of refurbishing my roof sign in the not too distant future. In my case I have been shit upon from a height by NTA at every opportunity. I was forced to replace a 2016 MKIII Octavia that was in showroom condition with a poxy Chinese washing machine on wheels this year as 2016 cars were the only pre-2018 cars that got no age extension on account of COVID '19 anall. The clawback on the subsidy I was given to buy the EV doesn't run out until 2029 so I now have no option to switch back to a diesel at all without losing that subsidy, assuming the new rules aren't pushed back as time progresses.
I will certainly add the negatives you have highlighted to my current list of negatives for further consideration in compiling my ultimate response. There's also another positive that I think you mentioned (possibly not a positive in your mind?) on another relevant thread in noting that the transition to EVs will present the mean and nasty MPOs with significantly increased costs. I definitely want to conduct some analysis of those fleets to contribute to my thought process ahead of finalising my submission.
-
I think, at this juncture, it's useful to reiterate what ITDF have suggested i.e. that drivers should submit submissions... even if you just want to tell NTA to go fuck itself, do that!
While nothing is likely to change during this process in any of the rules that have been set out we do know that age/vehicle standards rules have historically been reversed, pushed back or extended on a whim very frequently hence the decarbonisation consultation is, perhaps, most likely to be amended/disregarded as time progresses. Again, even if you only want to tell NTA that all you want is to provide minimum standards for maximum fares, tell them that!
-
I have made some unusual submissions in the past RC but my foot(or more my head)is halfway out the door of the business right now.Might regain some interest as Tap advances and grows but it's unlikely.
I will make a submission but they'll likely ignore it like they ignored my multiple submissions about the Rickshaws. I try not to wind myself up so I'll have a more limited input from now on.
-
I wonder if they have public service vehicles in Amerikkka?
Justice Dept. Accuses Lyft of Disability Discrimination in Lawsuit (https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/10/us/lyft-disability-lawsuit-doj.html) (Paywalled so don't click)
The Justice Department has accused Lyft and its drivers of 'routinely' refusing service to people with disabilities, including those who use wheelchairs and service animals.
Might awfully tempting for Irish drivers to skip these types of fares if they're hustling to do 30% discounted fares. I might be happy to do 10 x €10 fares to make €100 but I'd have to do 14 x €10 jobs @ 30% discount to make €100. Time is money so couldn't be waiting around for these guys to get into my taxi >:D
-
2017 - Lawsuit claims Uber discriminates against wheelchair riders (https://www.cnbc.com/2017/07/19/lawsuit-claims-uber-discriminates-against-wheelchair-riders.html)
2016 - 2024 - Timeline of Events in ERC’s Disability Discrimination Lawsuit Against Uber (https://equalrightscenter.org/timeline-lawsuit-uber-2024/)
2025 - US government sues Uber, alleging discrimination against disabled passengers (https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/sep/11/us-government-uber-lawsuit)
Hmmm...
-
When Uber offers % discounts that comes out of their pocket not the driver's. There haven't been any discounts on my rider app for the last few weeks. Uber doesn't offer fixed fare wheelchair accessible cars as such but that doesn't mean a WAV won't turn up to cover a fixed fare job, similarly it doesn't offer fixed fare EVs but that doesn't mean an EV won't turn up to cover a fixed fare job.
The fact that it doesn't offer fixed fare WAVs could be construed as discrimination, I guess?
NTAs new rules outlined in the Dispatch Operator consultation document will implement a more comprehensive complaints procedure for riders with the ultimate right to refer their complaint to NTA and NTA has mentioned it's intention to review the WA sector commencing next year so submitting concerns raised by those cases to the current DO consultation process might be worthwhile as it did say that some of the submissions to the initial submission phase of the DO review will prove useful when it commences that (WA) review.
-
It mightn't have happened here yet but it's widely acknowledged that drivers earnings fall substantially worldwide once Uber turns up on the scene. And it's been alleged multiple times over the years that Uber and other apps discriminate against less-abled people. Maybe the two are linked as drivers have to hustle hustle hustle to scrape a living? Whilst the NTA might not care too much about drivers earning enough to feed their families* (or child support for the man in a bedsit), they DO care about the less-abled. This concern might influence their next intervention in regulating the taxi game?
* then why bother with a biannual survey of drivers earnings and the max. fare rate?
-
Indeed, certainly worthy of consideration in any submission to the DO consultation process albeit in the knowledge that NTA has said it doesn't intend to implement any accessibility specific rules during this process as it has already scheduled a comprehensive review of the WAV sector to commence next year.
My little brain is still busy thinking about the decarbonisation consultation at present but I certainly will question Uber's suitability to hold a DO licence when I switch focus to that in the next week or two. I think there's plenty of examples of it knowingly and systematically manipulating it's systems to intentionally and deliberately mislead regulatory authorities in other jurisdictions which would call into question how it could be trusted within a regime that relies to a significant extent on systematic data reports from licensed dispatch operators. I would also suggest that, if not already provided for in law, there ought to be a procedure allowing objections to licences to be heard in a court of appropriate jurisdiction as is the case (afaik) in respect of publicans and bookmakers licenses. All food for thought, I guess.
As far as the decarbonisation consultation goes I'm leaning towards concluding that the intended transition to a 100% ZEV saloon fleet by 2037/8 is unnecessarily confrontational.
-
Although... I would note that I know men who have driven WAVs since they got the licences through Bertie's Forum who quite proudly boast about having never transported a wheelchair. Uber or no Uber an 8 ball will win over loading a wheelchair every time... probably? In fact, some of them only do school runs... which are a lot more lucrative than you might think.
-
I know Irish authorities have a tendency to ignore what happens around the world and try to reinvent the wheel every time something new comes along but the NTA could do worse than look across the pond before issuing Uber a DO licence.
Leaving aside Uber's repeated problems with HMRC re VAT, they also have repeated problems with their TfL operating licence. I can't find the link now but I'm pretty sure they had problems telling TfL all about the very many allegations of sexual assault etc against their 'partner drivers.' They also had a problem with their 'partner drivers' not speaking the English language well enough to pass a standard equivalent to our inter-cert level (~15 yrs of age).
In the USA, they periodically make their 'partner drivers' take selfies during their shift to prove it's not an imposter driving the Uber, again because of the many allegations of sexual assault etc.
I'm reminded of the old fable about the scorpion crossing the river which ends with it saying 'but that's my nature' as it kills its passenger. Having a guy and a nameplate over a door won't make Uber Inc. behave itself...
-
I know Irish authorities have a tendency to ignore what happens around the world and try to reinvent the wheel every time something new comes along but the NTA could do worse than look across the pond before issuing Uber a DO licence.
Leaving aside Uber's repeated problems with HMRC re VAT, they also have repeated problems with their TfL operating licence. I can't find the link now but I'm pretty sure they had problems telling TfL all about the very many allegations of sexual assault etc against their 'partner drivers.' They also had a problem with their 'partner drivers' not speaking the English language well enough to pass a standard equivalent to our inter-cert level (~15 yrs of age).
In the USA, they periodically make their 'partner drivers' take selfies during their shift to prove it's not an imposter driving the Uber, again because of the many allegations of sexual assault etc.
I'm reminded of the old fable about the scorpion crossing the river which ends with it saying 'but that's my nature' as it kills its passenger. Having a guy and a nameplate over a door won't make Uber Inc. behave itself...
Ask Peter Griffin:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vwy8i7rtYo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vwy8i7rtYo)
-
lol lol lol
-
To keep you happy Rodent I made a submission ?
-
To keep you happy Rodent I made a submission ?
I was impressed by your submission John. Alas, it's merely a box ticking exercise to make us feel our opinion matters.
-
To keep you happy Rodent I made a submission ?
I was impressed by your submission John. Alas, it's merely a box ticking exercise to make us feel our opinion matters.
Not sure Brian .Nobody else will see it through my lenz including the Committed definitely, not the fucking muppets who say they represent this industry .Do you think SIPTU would allow them Promote Isolation and victimisation of workers .Do you think any other industry would stand for dual standards of existing participant's? .
The real pity is the people who think they represent this industry ask Participant to engage after they done huge damage to the industry by claiming to represent more than the few dozen they actually do , made idiotic submissions .Now they ask people to save their skin by making intelligent submissions .
-
Silver I would be happy enough to see them force men out of the industry by increasing fees imposing ZEV on them it suits me I have an EV and home charging BUT and it is a BIG BUT and I raised it in my submission WHO IS NEXT ? So I quote John Donne ..No man is an island,
Entire of itself.
Each is a piece of the continent,
A part of the main.
If a clod be washed away by the sea,
Europe is the less.
As well as if a promontory were.
As well as if a manor of thine own
Or of thine friend's were.
Each man's death diminishes me,
For I am involved in mankind.
Therefore, send not to know
For whom the bell tolls,
It tolls for thee.
IF we do not stand togeather we Fall bit by bit .
-
It's the internet so you have to throw in a Nazi reference (Godwins Law (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law))
First They Came – by Pastor Martin Niemöller
First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me
-
It's the internet so you have to throw in a Nazi reference (Godwins Law (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law))
First They Came – by Pastor Martin Niemöller
First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me
Watty I have little or no interest in the Taxi industry its Frankies Vision Now a part time Gig ..I doubt a man working just 40 hours could bring home average industrial wages after costs in fact I doubt he could earn minimum wage .Like I said it suits me a 7 year limit and a Zev future .But what if I decide to stay on in 7 years ill be 72 plenty of men that age still participating .Can I find the price of a non subsidized replacement motor ?Possibly not can others find the cost of replacement non Subsidised motors .What then an Industry that Financially cannot sustain itself ? I proffer an answer and ask for a clear direction as envisaged by the NTA for our industry ? We do not have one in this proposed change .My last forecast was on Roys when I predicted exactly what we have now I called it Workcapture . Drivers got EXACTLY WHAT THEY DESERVED giving up 5 minutes waiting time .The PUC embracing % comissions to Promote Hailo .
-
I agree with you. I think most of us will be caught out in a few years when vehicle renewal time comes along and I could easily see the apps and MPO's becoming dominant and the majority of drivers renting from them. The result will be partly from pressure from the apps/MPOs* and partly because it'll suit the NTA better to deal with a handful of large orgs rather than 20,000 drivers.
* Capitalism (so-called competition) tends towards monopolies/duopolies >:D
-
I agree with you. I think most of us will be caught out in a few years when vehicle renewal time comes along and I could easily see the apps and MPO's becoming dominant and the majority of drivers renting from them. The result will be partly from pressure from the apps/MPOs* and partly because it'll suit the NTA better to deal with a handful of large orgs rather than 20,000 drivers.
* Capitalism (so-called competition) tends towards monopolies/duopolies >:D
What happens if the EU imposes tarriffs on non EU manufactured EVs ? We know the 10K grant comes from outside the Transport industry and can dry up at any time .Wrap arounds for Gaffs ,Solar Panels .EV are they not Environmental issues .Is the Taxi industry being used to Virtue Signal and fulfill some Eu Directive .My submission does exactly what they required askes how they reached the Decisions Offers on Solutions as that process has resulted in these proposals .So their question is what do you think my proposal is Prove what you propose .
-
It's the internet so you have to throw in a Nazi reference (Godwins Law (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law))
First They Came – by Pastor Martin Niemöller
First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me
All this talk of rite wing and left wing is all nonsense .......
Facism is not capitalism .... in fact Hitler formed thr National Socialist German Workers' Party .... so called " communist " russia and china murdered Millions of ther own ... today we have the so called left calling for the death of all jews and aligning itself with a death cult that is presently engaged in the slaughter of millions of ther own and anyone and everyone else ..... we have so called socialists in kildare street aligning themselves with the terrorist state of iran which has murdered thousands of its own citizens for merely protesting and which was behind the war started by islamists on October 7th when 1200 innocent jews where massacred ...
Its not us and them left or right .. its good and evil ... thers always a scapegoat
-
I know Irish authorities have a tendency to ignore what happens around the world and try to reinvent the wheel every time something new comes along but the NTA could do worse than look across the pond before issuing Uber a DO licence.
Leaving aside Uber's repeated problems with HMRC re VAT, they also have repeated problems with their TfL operating licence. I can't find the link now but I'm pretty sure they had problems telling TfL all about the very many allegations of sexual assault etc against their 'partner drivers.' They also had a problem with their 'partner drivers' not speaking the English language well enough to pass a standard equivalent to our inter-cert level (~15 yrs of age).
In the USA, they periodically make their 'partner drivers' take selfies during their shift to prove it's not an imposter driving the Uber, again because of the many allegations of sexual assault etc.
I'm reminded of the old fable about the scorpion crossing the river which ends with it saying 'but that's my nature' as it kills its passenger. Having a guy and a nameplate over a door won't make Uber Inc. behave itself...
It's not a road I'd go down myself. TfL is responsible for licensing and vetting PH drivers in London just as NTA via An Garda Siochana is here do that's a dead end. The DO review does credit rideshare platforms with enhancing passenger safety which is pretty much beyond dispute, IMO. The alternative would probably be smart meters that would require biometrics to unlock periodically, I guess. We can do without that, IMO but if there's an avenue to object to licence applications that's among a lot of things some of the unions could play with going forward.
-
To keep you happy Rodent I made a submission ?
Well done. If you can do it there's no excuse for anyone, I guess.
I do agree with SB that it's at the box ticking stage as far as the current review goes but, as noted above, it's no harm to get your thoughts together for any future lobbying you might engage in.
-
Watty I have little or no interest in the Taxi industry its Frankies Vision Now a part time Gig ..I doubt a man working just 40 hours could bring home average industrial wages after costs in fact I doubt he could earn minimum wage .Like I said it suits me a 7 year limit and a Zev future .But what if I decide to stay on in 7 years ill be 72 plenty of men that age still participating .Can I find the price of a non subsidized replacement motor ?Possibly not can others find the cost of replacement non Subsidised motors .What then an Industry that Financially cannot sustain itself ? I proffer an answer and ask for a clear direction as envisaged by the NTA for our industry ? We do not have one in this proposed change .My last forecast was on Roys when I predicted exactly what we have now I called it Workcapture . Drivers got EXACTLY WHAT THEY DESERVED giving up 5 minutes waiting time .The PUC embracing % comissions to Promote Hailo .
A ton a week gives you 50 large over 10 years. If you intend keeping your Chinese washing machine on wheels just start saving to replace it now. You, unlike me, do have the option of switching back to a diesel (that you could use 'till 2037) towards the back end of next year without suffering any clawback of the subsidy Govt gave you to buy your EV. That 'd most likely see you into calling for last on the great cab stand in the sky?
I have a few chats with drivers over the last few days and I do agree that NTA is being a little over-enthusiastic in aiming for a 100% EV Saloon fleet by 2037. These EVs aren't around long enough to know if they're up to the job and simply ringing a handful of drivers in the middle of one of the hottest summers on record and asking them how much they're saving on fuel doesn't amount to a comprehensive study upon which reasonable conclusions can be drawn. It might be more useful for NTA to take a step back and have a look at EV drivers' accounts as submitted to Revenue over a period of a number of years to get some useful information, for example.
-
I agree with you. I think most of us will be caught out in a few years when vehicle renewal time comes along and I could easily see the apps and MPO's becoming dominant and the majority of drivers renting from them. The result will be partly from pressure from the apps/MPOs* and partly because it'll suit the NTA better to deal with a handful of large orgs rather than 20,000 drivers.
* Capitalism (so-called competition) tends towards monopolies/duopolies >:D
Interesting. Where would you envisage MPOs getting more plates... do you think they'll go WAV, ZEWAV, PHEWAV or do you suspect NTA will lift the current temporary moratorium on the issue of saloon plates to accommodate them... or will they go with Limos and press Govt to lift the current temporary moratorium on the issue of saloon hackney plates... or will they just rent plates from us for 5 large a year... or something else?
I'm genuinely interested in your opinion on this, BTW.
I have had a very brief look at the bigger fleet operators and the only one that has any significant number of EVs at present is Stuart Kessie / Public Service Vehicles Ltd ( http://intaxi.org/database/mpo-mod.php?q=stuart%20kessie (http://intaxi.org/database/mpo-mod.php?q=stuart%20kessie) http://intaxi.org/database/mpo-mod.php?q=public%20service%20vehicles (http://intaxi.org/database/mpo-mod.php?q=public%20service%20vehicles) ). Of course, Stuart was clever enough to split his plates between his personal ownership and his company prior to normal plate transfer being prohibited hence he can, presumably, claim the maximum grant aid allowed per person twice each year.
-
The NTA could simply issue more plates - new blood needed and a semi-clapped out fleet demands it.
Or issue a new category of plate with, say, 60% reserved for current licencees (cf LAHs).
(https://i.ibb.co/tMWdswRg/Taxi-Driver-Age-Oct-2026.jpg)
1/3 of drivers over the age of 60 and almost 2/3 over the age of 50. Those drivers are gonna die off/retire. You can leave your licence to a person or company upon your death (PDF (https://www.nationaltransport.ie/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Guide-G15-Nomination-and-Assignment-2026.pdf)). Licences have no monetary value so no Capital Gains etc and I'm sure there's a clever way of renting your licence to a MPO for a bag of crisps/yr and then to the MPO after your death. Pay the licence owner a few quid for consulting or something.
It's more likely that all those licences will disappear into a black hole as drivers either just let them lapse or leave their licences to the spouse/children and almost none of them will continue the proud tradition of taxi driving... It is or will become a industry for part-timers to make pocket money for awhile.
So new blood needed...
(https://i.ibb.co/MFkFRvR/Taxi-Vehicle-Age-Oct-2026.jpg)
Shockingly, there's still 20% of the fleet over 10 yrs old, although some of them are WATs etc. But ~40% are over 7 yrs old and assuming the 10 yr is ever applied, they'll need replacing. There will be some who have savings who can afford to replace but only the MPO's have the balance sheet power to replace that much of the fleet quickly and with semi-decent vehicles. Maybe the MPO's could promise to make them all yellow or something?
The taxi industry is rapidly changing, particularly with respect to demographics.
Add in the potential introduction of robotaxis in, say, 10-15 years and it's not an attractive industry for someone in their 20's or 30's looking for a career.
If I'm a NTA executive (I won't say planner) and I'm looking 5-10 years into the future, the MPOs with their balance sheet power and the apps with their shiny shiny technology-fixes-everything, letting the two of them run riot would look like an attractive option? It's the way the world is going nowadays anyways with consolidation going on in all industries, e.g., when was the last time you bought a pint of milk from Jamie in Jamie's independent corner shop?
-
The NTA could simply issue more plates - new blood needed and a semi-clapped out fleet demands it.
Or issue a new category of plate with, say, 60% reserved for current licencees (cf LAHs).
(https://i.ibb.co/tMWdswRg/Taxi-Driver-Age-Oct-2026.jpg)
1/3 of drivers over the age of 60 and almost 2/3 over the age of 50. Those drivers are gonna die off/retire. You can leave your licence to a person or company upon your death (PDF (https://www.nationaltransport.ie/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Guide-G15-Nomination-and-Assignment-2026.pdf)). Licences have no monetary value so no Capital Gains etc and I'm sure there's a clever way of renting your licence to a MPO for a bag of crisps/yr and then to the MPO after your death. Pay the licence owner a few quid for consulting or something.
It's more likely that all those licences will disappear into a black hole as drivers either just let them lapse or leave their licences to the spouse/children and almost none of them will continue the proud tradition of taxi driving... It is or will become a industry for part-timers to make pocket money for awhile.
So new blood needed...
(https://i.ibb.co/MFkFRvR/Taxi-Vehicle-Age-Oct-2026.jpg)
Shockingly, there's still 20% of the fleet over 10 yrs old, although some of them are WATs etc. But ~40% are over 7 yrs old and assuming the 10 yr is ever applied, they'll need replacing. There will be some who have savings who can afford to replace but only the MPO's have the balance sheet power to replace that much of the fleet quickly and with semi-decent vehicles. Maybe the MPO's could promise to make them all yellow or something?
The taxi industry is rapidly changing, particularly with respect to demographics.
Add in the potential introduction of robotaxis in, say, 10-15 years and it's not an attractive industry for someone in their 20's or 30's looking for a career.
If I'm a NTA executive (I won't say planner) and I'm looking 5-10 years into the future, the MPOs with their balance sheet power and the apps with their shiny shiny technology-fixes-everything, letting the two of them run riot would look like an attractive option? It's the way the world is going nowadays anyways with consolidation going on in all industries, e.g., when was the last time you bought a pint of milk from Jamie in Jamie's independent corner shop?
Great post ...
-
Does anybody know .How many members these Rep bodies actually represent .Is there a membership Fee .How do you become a member who elects the Boards ? Imagine The Minister just sees them a Caucus to play with and can report back to the Cabinet for the twenty seven seconds per Dail Term of 4 years that the taxi industry is discussed ,Yes Taoiseach we consulted the Industry representatives .
-
Minister ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------> NTA --> Advisory Committee on Small Public Service Vehicles (https://www.nationaltransport.ie/about-us/advisory-committee-on-spsvs/) --> Shajedul Chowdhury, Francis Doheny, Alan Cooley is President of the Irish Taxi Drivers’ Federation (ITDF), & Anthony Kelly is the Chief Executive Officer of Trip Taxi Group, an organisation that encompasses several well-established and highly regarded dispatch companies, including VIP Taxis, Cab 2000, and NXT.