Author Topic: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000  (Read 918 times)

Offline watty

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8650
  • Karma: +0/-0
18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« on: September 01, 2024, 05:52:43 pm »
Wow!  Just wow  :o :o :o

New bicycle shed for Leinster house cost over €335k

Quote
A new bicycle shed for Leinster House which allows for storage of eighteen bikes cost more than €335,000.  The shelter, which was hailed by Transport Minister Eamon Ryan as a good example of public sector climate action, even required archaeological advice to make sure it fit in at the parliamentary complex.

A breakdown of costs from the Office of Public Works shows that €322,282 was spent on the main construction and installation project.  A further €2,952 was spent on archaeological services while €10,816 was paid for quantity surveying services and “contract administration services”.

The huge bill has raised eyebrows in Leinster House, but the Office of Public Works said a high-quality structure was needed because of its sensitive location.  Asked for a copy of the business case for the project, the OPW said none had been needed.  In an information note, they said: “The work referred to was carried out … as part of the ongoing essential maintenance and upgrade works that are undertaken within the Leinster House Complex and other OPW-owned buildings.  “This is one of the core functions and responsibilities of OPW and to this end there is a continuous programme of essential fabric and upgrade works identified by the OPW team responsible for the complex, working with Oireachtas Facilities.”

Asked for a copy of the scoping documents involved in the work, the Office of Public Works refused to provide them.  They claimed these had been prepared as part of a planning application and could not be released for “security reasons”.

The stand was built with a special cantilevered canopy that is designed to protect from the prevailing northerly winds.  It has not been fully enclosed however, with some believing it leaves their bikes too exposed to the elements.

I wonder if there'll be any 'room at the inn' for the (new record  ::clap ) 14,500 homeless people in our Republic?
Getting old is compulsory whilst growing up is voluntary.

Offline watty

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8650
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« Reply #1 on: September 02, 2024, 03:51:55 pm »
https://www.rte.ie/news/2024/0902/1467936-leinster-house-bike-shed/

Quote
Minister for Transport Eamon Ryan has said the Office of Public Works has questions to answer after it emerged that a bicycle shed installed at Leinster House last year cost an estimated €335,000.

Mr Ryan said the cost of the shed to store 18 bikes seems to be "incredibly expensive".  "I look forward to listening to the OPW and talking to the OPW as to why it was so expensive," he said.  ''They [may] have their own reasons, but I must admit I was shocked when I saw the price, we need to do things cheaper than that all over the country."   Mr Ryan said the Government has to show that "we spend public money wisely and that sort of cost seems to be very, very high".  The minister also said that growing numbers are using public transport and that more bus shelters are needed all over the country.

The Taoiseach said he has no knowledge or information in relation to the bike shed.  "I do think it's very important that public money is always carefully spent," Simon Harris told RTÉ News during a press conference at Farmleigh House, adding that the issue is "matter for the Oireachtas".

The shelter, previously hailed by Mr Ryan as a good example of public sector climate action, even required archaeological advice to make sure it fit in at the parliamentary complex.  A breakdown of costs from the OPW shows that €322,282 was spent on the main construction and installation project.  A further €2,952 was spent on archaeological services while €10,816 was paid for quantity surveying services and "contract administration services".

Still, I suppose it wasn't €62.5 million on a water pipe and a bicycle lane down in North Strand! 

https://www.dublincity.ie/residential/transportation/active-travel/projects/clontarf-city-centre-project/faqs-and-resource-hub/faqs#a24150-24148

Quote
- The overall length of the Project is 2.7km
- 6km of new and upgraded cycling lanes
- 5.4km of upgraded bus lanes
- 8km of upgraded pedestrian walkways
- €62.5 million is the Project budget
Getting old is compulsory whilst growing up is voluntary.

Offline silverbullet

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 26693
  • Karma: +2/-0
  • You don't want to do it like that
Re: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« Reply #2 on: September 02, 2024, 04:32:04 pm »
https://www.rte.ie/news/2024/0902/1467936-leinster-house-bike-shed/

Quote
Minister for Transport Eamon Ryan has said the Office of Public Works has questions to answer after it emerged that a bicycle shed installed at Leinster House last year cost an estimated €335,000.

Mr Ryan said the cost of the shed to store 18 bikes seems to be "incredibly expensive".  "I look forward to listening to the OPW and talking to the OPW as to why it was so expensive," he said.  ''They [may] have their own reasons, but I must admit I was shocked when I saw the price, we need to do things cheaper than that all over the country."   Mr Ryan said the Government has to show that "we spend public money wisely and that sort of cost seems to be very, very high".  The minister also said that growing numbers are using public transport and that more bus shelters are needed all over the country.

The Taoiseach said he has no knowledge or information in relation to the bike shed.  "I do think it's very important that public money is always carefully spent," Simon Harris told RTÉ News during a press conference at Farmleigh House, adding that the issue is "matter for the Oireachtas".

The shelter, previously hailed by Mr Ryan as a good example of public sector climate action, even required archaeological advice to make sure it fit in at the parliamentary complex.  A breakdown of costs from the OPW shows that €322,282 was spent on the main construction and installation project.  A further €2,952 was spent on archaeological services while €10,816 was paid for quantity surveying services and "contract administration services".

Still, I suppose it wasn't €62.5 million on a water pipe and a bicycle lane down in North Strand! 

https://www.dublincity.ie/residential/transportation/active-travel/projects/clontarf-city-centre-project/faqs-and-resource-hub/faqs#a24150-24148

Quote
- The overall length of the Project is 2.7km
- 6km of new and upgraded cycling lanes
- 5.4km of upgraded bus lanes
- 8km of upgraded pedestrian walkways
- €62.5 million is the Project budget
Who can forget this massive blunder?
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/politics/purchase-of-printer-too-big-to-fit-inside-dail-investigated-1.4095419#:~:text=Oireachtas%20spent%20%E2%82%AC230%2C000%20to%20fit%20printer%20into%20Leinster%20House%20after%20measurement%20error&text=The%20clerk%20of%20D%C3%A1il%20%C3%89ireann,to%20fit%20inside%20the%20building.

Offline watty

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8650
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« Reply #3 on: September 02, 2024, 05:28:17 pm »
 lol
Getting old is compulsory whilst growing up is voluntary.

Offline Bubba Ho-Tep

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1418
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« Reply #4 on: September 03, 2024, 12:51:58 pm »
Three contractors from Mayo, Kildare & Kerry tendered for the bike shelter at Leinster house.
They were interviewed by an OPW officer
The Mayo man quoted €100,000 the OPW officer asked for a breakdown in the figures the Mayo man said “€33,000 for parts €33,000 for labour & €34,000 profit”
The Kildare man quoted €150,000 and his breakdown was €50,000 for parts €50,000 for labour & €50,000 profit.
The Kerry man quoted €300,000, the officer was shocked at the price & asked for his breakdown the Kerry man said “well it’s €100,000 for me, €100,000 for you & we give the job to the Mayo man..

Offline silverbullet

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 26693
  • Karma: +2/-0
  • You don't want to do it like that
Re: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« Reply #5 on: September 03, 2024, 01:55:43 pm »
Three contractors from Mayo, Kildare & Kerry tendered for the bike shelter at Leinster house.
They were interviewed by an OPW officer
The Mayo man quoted €100,000 the OPW officer asked for a breakdown in the figures the Mayo man said “€33,000 for parts €33,000 for labour & €34,000 profit”
The Kildare man quoted €150,000 and his breakdown was €50,000 for parts €50,000 for labour & €50,000 profit.
The Kerry man quoted €300,000, the officer was shocked at the price & asked for his breakdown the Kerry man said “well it’s €100,000 for me, €100,000 for you & we give the job to the Mayo man..
It's a Niall Tobin yarn, but a good one. 8)

Offline Bubba Ho-Tep

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1418
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« Reply #6 on: September 03, 2024, 03:25:12 pm »
Three contractors from Mayo, Kildare & Kerry tendered for the bike shelter at Leinster house.
They were interviewed by an OPW officer
The Mayo man quoted €100,000 the OPW officer asked for a breakdown in the figures the Mayo man said “€33,000 for parts €33,000 for labour & €34,000 profit”
The Kildare man quoted €150,000 and his breakdown was €50,000 for parts €50,000 for labour & €50,000 profit.
The Kerry man quoted €300,000, the officer was shocked at the price & asked for his breakdown the Kerry man said “well it’s €100,000 for me, €100,000 for you & we give the job to the Mayo man..
It's a Niall Tobin yarn, but a good one. 8)
I sold him the joke for a £5

Offline markmiwurdz

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4331
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« Reply #7 on: September 03, 2024, 07:10:44 pm »
A bargain at 18.6 K per vermin. ::fds

Offline watty

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8650
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« Reply #8 on: September 03, 2024, 08:00:11 pm »


Looks like it's open on 3 sides.  Imagine the cost if they had to build a few walls as well  ::)

Photo from The Journal
Getting old is compulsory whilst growing up is voluntary.

Offline silverbullet

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 26693
  • Karma: +2/-0
  • You don't want to do it like that
Re: 18-bay bike shed in Leinster House cost €335,000
« Reply #9 on: September 10, 2024, 02:00:30 pm »


Looks like it's open on 3 sides.  Imagine the cost if they had to build a few walls as well  ::)

Photo from The Journal
This is the guy responsible for the shelter:




Former head of the OPW, and current president of Engineers Ireland.
https://x.com/oconnellhugh/status/1832705144695247337

https://www.thetimes.com/world/ireland-world/article/office-of-public-works-paid-for-retiring-bosss-paris-study-trips-grz5msjfb

State paid for retiring Office of Public Works boss’s Paris study trips
Taxpayer footed the bill of over €35,000 for agency’s former chairman to attend a business school in Paris less than a year before he retired
Claire Scott, Political Correspondent
Sunday September 08 2024, 12.01am BST, The Sunday Times
Ireland
The OPW paid €1,660.60 in 2023 for Maurice Buckley’s transport, accommodation and subsistence costs over five days
The OPW paid €1,660.60 in 2023 for Maurice Buckley’s transport, accommodation and subsistence costs over five days
ORLA MURRAY/COALESCE
The state paid more than €35,000 for the former Office of Public Works (OPW) chairman to attend a prestigious business school in Paris less than a year before he retired.

Maurice Buckley, who was at the helm of the OPW when the €336,000 Leinster House bicycle shelter was approved, attended an 18-day executive course over three visits between 2022 and 2023.

The Department of Public Expenditure, NDP Delivery and Reform (Dpendr) and the Office of Public Works split the €33,718 cost of the course. His flights and expenses were also paid.

Best of Times Ireland newsletter: The most compelling Irish news, business, sport and lifestyle stories from the week, every Sunday. Sign up with one click
Buckley’s term as chairman came to an end on April 19 this year. The OPW said the cost would have been value for money if ­Buckley, who now describes himself on his LinkedIn account as self-employed, had continued working in the state sector.

According to figures released to The Sunday Times under freedom of information laws, the OPW paid €1,660.60 in 2023 for Buckley’s transport, accommodation and subsistence for his five-day trip on May 7-12, 2023.

Advertisement

While the OPW told The Sunday Times that the course was a “fully approved investment that was sanctioned by Dpendr/senior public service team”, Dpendr has denied this. It said its role at the time was to make contributions to the cost of leadership development programmes and, as Buckley was the head of his department, he could approve his own training. Dpendr said: “The decision to participate in any training programme is a matter for the relevant department and the relevant secretary-general, in this case the chairman of the OPW.”

Buckley attended the course at Insead for nine days in November 2022 and five days in February 2023, but his expenses for these trips are not yet available. Asked why the OPW had approved an overseas course for a chairman who was retiring, a spokeswoman said: “It was envisaged at the time the programme was sanctioned and undertaken by the former chairman that he was likely to have continued involvement in the state sector potentially on state boards and committees following the conclusion of his term of office. In such circumstances the investment in the programme would continue to be of value to the state.”

Asked why a leadership programme at an Irish college or university was not considered suitable, the OPW said: “We are seeking clarification on this.”

Insead is one of the world’s leading business schools, with campuses in Singapore, Abu Dhabi and Fontainebleau, just outside Paris. Buckley was contacted for comment.





 


Show Unread Posts