https://consult.nationaltransport.ie/en/consultation/spsv-dispatch-operator-consultationhttps://consult.nationaltransport.ie/en/system/files/materials/25666/NTA%20Dispatch%20Operator%20Consultation%20Paper.pdfhttps://consult.nationaltransport.ie/en/system/files/materials/25666/Draft%20Statutory%20Instrument%20-%20Dispatch%20Operator%20Regulations.pdfKey pointsTiered Licencing SystemThe new DO licensing regulations will introduce three distinct categories of licence based on a tiered system with licence fees of €100, €3,000 and €10,000. The consultation document specifies trip numbers as the metric used to differentiate between categories. However it goes on to suggest that:
The NTA recognises that trip numbers fluctuate, and that other measures, such as revenue or fleet size, could be used to classify operators. The NTA welcomes views on the thresholds, the metric used and the proposed process for estimating and confirming trip numbers.
I would suggest that Revenue might be the best fit for a co-operative society.
The fact that NTA has seen fit to regulate dispatch operators on a discriminatory basis ought to be seem as a big win for drivers and undoubtedly serves as a shot across the bow of Uber by letting Uber know that NTA is in charge with the veiled threat of further restrictive regulation if Uber doesn't toe the line.
Licence DurationUnder the new regulations NTA will issue DO licences for a period of up to 12 months rather than periods of 12 months under the current regime. Obviously, that just allows NTA to cancel licences before they expire / come up for renewal if a dispatch operator is bold and doesn't come across with whatever might be deemed necessary in considering the extent of such bold behaviour.
Limousine booking services includedPreviously exempt limousine booking services will be included under the new regulatory framework. The rationale for that decision is that riders can now Uber a Limousine so NTA obviously considers it appropriate to extend the protections of using a licensed dispatch operator's services to those riders including establishing a maximum booking fee in respect of such bookings.
Physical Presence in IrelandThe new regulations will require licensed dispatch operators to maintain an operating centre or office in Ireland and where the applicant is not resident in Ireland the applicant must nominate a designated responsible person who is resident in Ireland. That ought to require Uber to account for VAT directly to the Irish exchequer. Whether that's a good thing or not depends on your opinion. Pretty much all drivers' unions who addressed the Oireachtas Committee identified the reverse charge regime as unnecessarily cumbersome for drivers. On the other hand it makes it a lot easier and cheaper for the thicker lads who wouldn't be capable of making VAT returns to work for Uber which many might not consider to be such a good thing.
Data ReportingDispatch operators will be required to periodically submit data to NTA to facilitate oversight and contribute to such further regulatory reviews as may be deemed appropriate. The data sets required vary in accordance with the (tiered) licence category. Drivers are probably most interested in large dispatch operators such as Uber and Free Now by Lyft. For that (highest tier) category trip level data will be required in addition to aggregated summaries. What's blatantly missing from every data set is the amount of commission charged.
Driver Commission / IncentivesThe consultation document states that:
On the presumption of the retention of a regulated system of clear maximum prices, the NTA does not see a basis at this juncture to makes proposals to regulate the commission and incentive structures between drivers and dispatch operators, or to unnecessarily limit dispatch operator service offerings. As the market evolves over time, the NTA will keep these matters under review.
Given that the data sets mentioned above do not include commission charged to drivers NTA will be conducting any relevant reviews with one hand tied behind it's back.
Protecting the Regulated Fare StructureThe draft S.I. provides that:
63A. (1) A fee may be charged by a dispatch operator in connection with a booking service or
the booking of a small public service vehicle only if:
(a) such fee, together with any amount payable to the driver by way of booking fee,
does not exceed €3.00; and
(b) such fee is fixed and does not vary or change by reference to circumstances
applicable to the hire of the small public service vehicle, such as time of hire,
duration of hire, distance travelled during the hire, place of hire or demand for hire.
(2) Where a dispatch operator receives payment of a fare from a passenger in respect of a
journey, the aggregate payable by the passenger to the dispatch operator shall not
exceed the maximum amount that would have been payable to the driver for that
journey under any order made under section 24 of the Principal Act.
Essentially that serves to prohibit any surcharges over and above those included in the maximum fare permitted by law in accordance with the taximeter in the case of taxis or over €3 in the case of limousines and hackneys "whether described as a booking fee, dispatch fee, technology fee, premium fee or otherwise". Paragraph 1(b) dictates that the fee charged must be consistent in amount and application. The dispatch operator is also required to issue an electronic invoice showing all information as displayed on printed receipts issued by licensed taximen/taxi drivers in accordance with Regulation 56(2) of S.I. 33/2015.
However the consultation document does mention ancillary services separate to regulated services, stating that:
The NTA proposes certain requirements to be met by dispatch operators, including where passengers receive a digital receipt, so that full break-down on fee components are set out, and that regulated service charges are fully separated from any ancillary unregulated services
The new regulations also prohibit charging cancellation fees. The rationale behind that is given as providing riders who choose to pay by electronic means with a level playing field as, while drivers are no longer entitled to legal tender (cash), drivers are still legally required to accept cash at the rider's discretion. NTA suggests that it is not always possible to apply cancellation fees to cash rides. However, NTA will review that policy as it receives data from dispatch operators.
Complaints ProcedureLicensed dispatch operators will be required to maintain and advertise comprehensive consumer complaints procedures which will include informing the consumer that he may refer his complaint to NTA. There is no requirement to maintain a complaints procedure for drivers.
Driver AlignmentReferencing the initial consultation phase of this review - to which it received 538 submissions - NTA notes that:
Where commented on, respondents argued that the NTA should not specify rules around affiliation, whether mandatory or exclusive. The NTA agrees with this, and allowing drivers to choose to work with some, many or no dispatch operators is considered key in enhancing market outcomes for both drivers and passengers.
AccessibilityAt this juncture NTA has opted not to make any WA specific changes to dispatch operator licensing regulation. The consultation document does, however, state that:
In our three-year regulatory strategy, we have set out that we will review the experience of wheelchair users of SPSV services commencing in 2027. The many comments and suggestions on this topic received will be very useful in this regard.
The biggest two dots to join in this process might be the apparent decision to allow Uber branding on Limousines and bringing Limousine dispatch operators into the dispatch operator licensing regime.
Any thoughts?