62
« Last post by Rat Catcher on November 12, 2026, 02:05:13 pm »
In considering my own submission to the SPSV Decarbonisation Consultation I have noted the following:
Changes to Age rules
- 7yr rule for saloon cars, 12yr rule for WAVs
For saloon cars the lowered age limit only applies to non-ZEVs first licensed in 2028. Easily avoidable by changing the car in 2027.
For WAVs the lowered limit will apply to non-ZEVs/PHEVs first licensed from 2028 onward. Lowered limit is still higher than existing limit that applies to saloon vehicles hence there's not a whole lot to get excited about.
For legacy WAVs age limits will apply which subject those 48 vehicles to the same rules as apply to everyone else. Again no big deal unless you happen to own one or some of those plates and you feel that you should be treated as a special person with special needs.
Positive
- slight improvement to minimum standards as far as quality goes with some safety relevant improvements as safety related systems fitted to motor vehicles typically improve as time progresses.
Negative
- very slight increase to the cost of operating a WA taxi or hackney licence caused by more frequent changes of vehicle where a fossil fuel car is chosen.
Removal of Fossil Fuel cars from the saloon fleet
- from 2029 only ZEVs will be first licensed
Positives
- Good for the environment
- Potential improvements to safety as EVs typically require specialist servicing so ought to be more likely to be maintained to manufacturer specification than fossil fuel cars that may be subject to less stringent practices employed by back street garages or DIY repairs and maintenance.
- Reduced fuel costs for drivers who have access to home charging facilities.
- Feelgood factor for drivers who believe that they are saving the planet by using cars that are powered by electricity that is generated from burning fossil fuels as opposed to the more fuel efficient traditional engines that burn fossil fuels directly with no power factor or electricity generation/distribution losses.
Negatives
- Bad for the environment. Using fossil fuel to generate and distribute electricity to power motor vehicles is considerably less efficient than powering vehicles directly with fossil fuels and the vehicles themselves weigh significantly more than equivalent fossil fuel powered vehicles. Basic physics tells us that it takes more energy to move more weight.
- Potential fire safety issues given that lithium batteries and the charging thereof has been identified as being quite high on the list of causes of house fires. If charging the battery of a little 12 year old mobile phone can burn a house down one can only imagine what damage EV batteries and the charging thereof may cause as they age.
- Increased traffic congestion. When an EV breaks down it typically becomes an immovable object which generally can't be simply pushed out of the way as is the case with a fossil fuel vehicle.
- Increased stress on the national grid. Creating incremental demand for electricity obviously increases whatever potential for shortages on the supply side might exist or might materialise due to circumstances beyond the control of the Irish authorities. In particular such demand could contribute to reducing supplies available to essential infrastructure such as data centres.
- Increased vehicle maintenance costs for drivers. Servicing of EVs is typically restricted to main dealers and specialist workshops which charge considerably higher rates than applicable to fossil fuel vehicles.
Increased licensing fees
In itself pretty insignificant as the increase of up to €875 only applies to first licensing of vehicles that run on fossil fuel. In the case of saloon vehicles it is easily avoided by changing the car in 2027 instead of 2028.
However, the concept of applying different fees to different circumstances as a tool to encourage the desired move to ZEVs is an interesting one and one that could have further potential. I intend to have a look at the 5 or 6 biggest MPOs to see how the proportion of EVs on their fleets compares to the entire fleet of licenced taxis. My thinking is that it could be beneficial to consider lifting the current temporary moratorium on the issue of saloon taxi plates in respect of EVs only with annual licence renewal fees set at a rate that would be considerably higher than applicable to the existing fleet but would equate to offering drivers a, perhaps marginally, cheaper alternative to being stuck in the rental market. Funds raised through such a scheme could be ringfenced to financing the provision of grant aided ZEV WA taxis. Such a scheme may also serve to make the trade more attractive to younger men.
Positives
- may encourage owners of WA vehicles to minimise the frequency of vehicle changes which has obvious environmental benefits.
- may encourage owners of WA vehicles to consider purchasing ZEVs or PHEVs.
Negative
- slightly increased overheads for drivers who refuse to provide ZEWAVs or PHEWAVs.
Grant Aid
NTA states that grant aid in respect of saloon ZEVs is determined by DoT so any phasing out is beyond it's control. Given the shambolic manner in which eSPSV26 was administered by NTA it is clear that DoT ought to be lobbied to find a competent organisation to administer any future schemes.
NTA states that it will continue to devise, administer and control WAV grant aid schemes going forward and suggests that from 2027 grant aid under those schemes will be focussed on the provision of ZEWAVs and PHEWAVs. That seems reasonable given that there has been scant interest in providing ZEWAVs or PHEWAVs to date. However, NTA justifies it's decision to restrict all first licensed saloon taxis and hackneys to ZEVs from 2029 by drawing refence to the fact that TfL restricted all first licenced taxis to ZEVs way back in 2018. London taxis are all WAVs which obviously calls into question why WAVs should enjoy exemption from the rules applicable to saloon taxis in this jurisdiction.
I would suggest that allocation of future grant aid should be focussed on existing participants, both owners of current WAV licences and drivers who have been forced into the rental market, in the first instance. Such focus could serve to attract younger men to the trade as it would serve to provide an avenue to progression.
Positive
- Grant aid is great for drivers who get it as it gives them a significant competitive edge over those who don't.
Negatives
- Grant aid puts those drivers whose applications for the same are unsuccessful at a considerable competitive disadvantage.
Dublin Airport Taxi Ranks
Taxi ranks at Dublin Airport are operated and controlled by Dublin Airport Authority. For some reason DAA remains the only authority in Ireland that is allowed regulate it's taxi services on a quantitative basis.
I recently hired a taxi from the rank at Dublin Airport and upon my travelling companion suggesting to the rank marshal that she'd prefer not to travel in the 15 year old converted cargo vehicle that was first in line we were directed to a clapped out 9 year old Toyota Prius. My travelling companion asked why I - as the owner driver of a brand new 2026 EV - don't work from that rank and was completely mystified to learn that I am not allowed. If this doesn't highlight the urgent need to implement qualitative rather than quantitative restrictions I don't know what will. If we look at airport taxi ranks around the world we are often met with choices between EVs or fossil fuel vehicles (e.g. Krakow which operates two distinct ranks) yet we are still greeting our international visitors with a third world service. Obviously, qualitative regulation would incentivise drivers to provide newer cars which would, in turn, accelerate NTAs decarbonisation programme.