At the beginning of his 214-page judgment, Justice Denis McDonald said he was “struck, quite forcefully” by the realisation that people who take out insurance might never truly know what they are signing up for.
The pubs-versus-FBD case shows how any policy is open to interpretation, after four business owners were forced to spend 11 days in the Commercial Court arguing the meaning of everyday words.
Chris Kelly, owner of Sinnotts Bar, said in his evidence that the policy was in “simple English”, but this detailed judgment shows nothing is straightforward with the English language when it comes to insurers parting with money.