Brian J Pierce is leading the field for me @ €1,920... Taxi Fair @ €2,100... Liberty out of the running @ way too much... First Ireland and Jim Mannion yet to weigh in. However, it varies for everybody so the best advice is to ring around.
Having a nightmare getting post from Liberty (my current insurer) at the moment. They sent my renewal documents on 21st December and last Tuesday and the cert/disc for my shitebox nua last Thursday but I haven't received any of it. Got on to them today and they emailed my NCD cert so I'll be able to renew elsewhere but they have no facility other than post for the other documents. Obviously, I can't book my LRA without the cert/disc so it's terribly inconvenient. Not getting any answer from An Post's DSU and the only way their post differs from everyone else's (which I am getting) is that they include the Eircode.
However, I won't pretend that I'm not pleased to be leaving Liberty. While the ladies on the phone are always pleasant and helpful I dealt with one absolute prick with a nordy accent last week (Michael, if memory serves) who insisted that I couldn't do a temporary transfer and that the firm "wouldn't let me own a car that isn't covered"... I done the temporary transfer a couple of days later with no problem other than being charged a fee (€36.75) which I believe is because my policy is within the renewal window.